Watch Webinar
The application of novel spectroscopic techniques is revolutionizing Art analysis, allowing conservators and researchers to unlock centuries-old secrets hidden within delicate artwork.
A recent collaborative study between researchers from the University of Antwerp in Belgium, the Rembrandt Museum in the Netherlands, and partners in France demonstrates how Optical Photothermal Infrared (O-PTIR) Spectroscopy provides crucial insights where conventional techniques fall short.
The Challenge: Analyzing Faded Pigments
The research focused on a small painting measuring approximately 70 centimeters that displays significant fading in its pink background. Understanding which pigment was originally used would enable conservators to potentially recreate the original appearance and develop strategies to prevent further degradation.
The challenge was substantial – sample extraction had to be extremely limited given the historical value of the artwork. Researchers were restricted to samples measuring approximately 200 by 25 microns (smaller than a human hair), making analysis difficult with conventional techniques.
Multi-layered Analysis Approach
The researchers prepared cross-sections of the minute samples embedded in synthetic resin to analyze the painting’s composition. The cross-section revealed multiple distinct layers:
- Canvas fibers with sizing glue
- A white ground layer approximately 10 microns thick
- The painting layer containing extremely small pigment particles around 2 microns in diameter
The team employed multiple analytical techniques to identify the elusive pink pigment:
- Synchrotron-based FTIR spectroscopy
- Raman spectroscopy
- Scanning electron microscopy with EDX
- Optical Photothermal Infrared (O-PTIR) spectroscopy
Key Findings
The breakthrough came when O-PTIR spectroscopy definitively identified genuine lake pigment as the source of the pink color in the background. While conventional techniques provided hints – Raman spectroscopy suggested possible genuine lake bands and EDX detected bromine associated with the pigment – only O-PTIR delivered unambiguous molecular identification.
Beyond identifying the pigment, the analysis revealed:
- The spatial distribution of different components across painting layers
- Lead white pigment predominantly in the upper layers
- Calcium carbonate distributed in the bottom and middle layers
- Drying oil spread throughout all layers
Technical Advantages of O-PTIR
The study highlighted several decisive advantages of O-PTIR over conventional techniques:
- Superior Spatial Resolution: With analysis spots as small as 450 by 250 nanometers, O-PTIR provided much higher resolution than synchrotron FTIR (6×3 microns) and conventional FTIR (30×30 microns).
- Non-contact Analysis: Unlike AFM-IR techniques that require physical contact and risk damaging fragile historical samples, O-PTIR analysis is completely non-contact.
- Excellent Spectral Quality: The spectra obtained showed low noise, flat baselines, and no spectral artifacts, with relative intensities comparable to transmission FTIR.
- Compatibility with Existing Databases: Spectra generated are directly comparable with established transmission FTIR databases, facilitating interpretation.
- Radiation Damage Prevention: Despite concerns about potential light damage to sensitive pigments, repeated measurements showed no spectral degradation.
- Fluorescence Rejection: The technique effectively filters out fluorescence through signal modulation, eliminating interference issues common in Raman analysis.
The researchers concluded that O-PTIR was the only technique capable of successfully characterizing the minute pink particles, demonstrating its exceptional potential for cultural heritage research. This capability to analyze microscopic samples with minimal preparation requirements opens new possibilities for preserving and understanding historical artworks without compromising their integrity.
The research was supported by the University of Antwerp, the Flanders Research Agency, and the Percy Control foundation.
